Forums

Forums (http://ism.ws/bulletin/index.php)
-   General Supply Management Discussions (http://ism.ws/bulletin/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Cost Savings Analysis (http://ism.ws/bulletin/showthread.php?t=350)

pledger1 01-28-2013 01:41 PM

Cost Savings Analysis
 
Just curious as to what savings calculators your company utilizes? I know they are several different formulas that are generally accepted, I'm just looking for real examples of what you are currently using.

We are currently using a average of bids. Which means we are combining all of the bids to get an average and then subtracting the low bid from that. It seems like an odd way to calculate savings, but that's what we doing currently.

Example:
Bid 1 = $100
Bid 2 = $150
Bid 3 = $125
Avg = $125 minus low bid (100) savings = $25

Any other suggestions?

Thanks.

daynagirl 03-11-2013 06:40 AM

Hi there, it is good but you can also start at a lower bid. Anyway, do you have savings? having a large chunk of cash in savings is always the very best thing to do so you can pay for any emergency situations that come your way. While you are working on building that money up, you may have emergencies still. Many people do not have the cash flow to put too much cash away anyway. When you have a crisis and need cash, you can use a pay day loan.

shannonaverett 04-17-2013 10:49 PM

Cost Savings Calculations
 
There are various ways that you can calculate cost savings. You have to first determine if it is a hard, soft, or 3-bid cost savings. The only cost savings that impact your financial statements is the hard cost savings. Hard cost savings is only relevant if you have historical pricing data.

Shannon




Quote:

Originally Posted by pledger1 (Post 654)
Just curious as to what savings calculators your company utilizes? I know they are several different formulas that are generally accepted, I'm just looking for real examples of what you are currently using.

We are currently using a average of bids. Which means we are combining all of the bids to get an average and then subtracting the low bid from that. It seems like an odd way to calculate savings, but that's what we doing currently.

Example:
Bid 1 = $100
Bid 2 = $150
Bid 3 = $125
Avg = $125 minus low bid (100) savings = $25

Any other suggestions?

Thanks.


blund 04-26-2013 07:11 PM

Cost Savings
 
We consider cost savings if the savings are negotiated off of a proposed price.
In the past I have also utilized historical pricing, but this doesn't take into consideration market changes and could impact your true cost savings.

ahrani82 12-16-2013 07:42 PM

I imposed the same logic to our cost savings calculation.

Cost saving = average of Evaluated bid prices - Resulting Contract Price

Evaluated bid prices = adjusted bid price after clarifications, negotiations and risk assessment
Resulting Contract Price = negotiated final value with the recommended bidder.

It is based on the simple logic that bids are a reflection of market price for goods/services. This would not apply to fuel or vehicles or other commodities or services that published unit rates are readily available.
So, if the bids prices viewed as market prices, then the average of bid prices are deemed as the market price.

However, if commodity you are buying has a set market rate, such as MSRP for vehicle, than I would calculate cost savings from MSRP since without tendering or negotiations, that is the set price for the goods.

Hope I have clarified how I perceive cost savings in supply chain as deductions obtained from tendering process.


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:18 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.